The Chief Legacy of 9/11

25 Years Later, A War of Terror Persists with No End in Sight

BILL ASTORE

SEP 09, 2026

The chief legacy of 9/11 is as obvious as it is tragic: a state of permanent warfare in the United States, both abroad and in the “homeland” (a term not used in normal discourse before the 9/11 attacks), with millions dead and displaced for no defensible reason.

If you’re 25 years old or younger in America, you’ve never known a time when your country wasn’t at war. “Peace” is no longer seen as desirable, let alone possible. War is seen as America’s natural state; a land of warriors are we, imbued with a “warrior ethos” that applauds kicking other countries when their down and beating the snot out of them just because we can.

Meanwhile, in the “homeland,” surveillance grows ever more intrusive by the day as agents of ICE kick down doors and haul people away to detention centers that are being rapidly expanded. Personal privacy is increasingly a thing of the past as the government wraps itself in a shroud of secrecy that makes oversight and accountability well-nigh impossible. 

The global war on terror has become a war of terror. War begets more war, with no end in sight.

Re-reading the Atlantic Monthly 150th anniversary issue from November 2007, I came across this gem of a quote from America’s 9/11 mayor, Rudolph Giuliani:

We’ve got to be patient and committed [in Iraq], but we’ve got to multitask … We’ve got to talk about Iran—Iran is more dangerous than Iraq—and we have got to get the job done in Afghanistan and in Pakistan.

That was Giuliani in July of 2007 when he ran as a Republican presidential candidate. In America, that’s how you get treated as a “serious” candidate for the presidency—by urging for war not just with Iraq and Afghanistan but with Pakistan and Iran as well. We can “multitask” our wars! Truly a sign of American greatness.

Well, Giuliani’s dream has come true—we are talking a lot about Iran today.

Back in 2007, Ron Paul had a different take on 9/11 and America’s state of forever war, but he was roundly booed for asking Americans to exercise just a bit of empathy by asking why “they” hate us:

That “crazy” Ron Paul, talking about blowback for America’s wars in the Middle East. He obviously didn’t know about America’s peace-making bombs and freedom-bringing missiles. Didn’t he know as well that “they” hate us for our freedoms?

One thought on “The Chief Legacy of 9/11

  1. Part of that legacy is an unwillingness to acknowledge, indeed a diversion from giving any attention to, “The motivations behind the September 11 attacks included retaliation against U.S. support for Israel, military presence in the Middle East, and a desire to liberate Muslim lands. Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden articulated these grievances in various statements leading up to the attacks” [History TV Channel, Wikipedia]. All reasonable explanations in my book. If one wishes to get into such contemplation, the horrors of that day still could not compare to the century of suffering by the Palestinians to that day, and the deprivations and desperations of Muslims at the hands of repressive regimes allied with the United States, in turn shackled to the corpse, or should that be zombie, of Israel.

    Like

Leave a comment