W.J. Astore
Pay Attention to What You Read
Here’s a typical quick summary of the dire situation in Gaza from CNN this AM:
The US is seeking to delay an Israeli ground offensive in Gaza amid calls to free more hostages held there by Hamas and allow aid into the besieged enclave. A senior Israeli official told CNN there will be “no ceasefire” in Gaza, but emphasized efforts are ongoing to free the more than 200 hostages in the region “as quickly as possible.” However, the official added, “humanitarian efforts cannot be allowed to impact the mission to dismantle Hamas.” More than 4,600 people have been killed in Gaza since October 7 and over 14,200 others wounded, the health ministry there said.
Conditions on the ground in Gaza continue to deteriorate as Israel repeatedly bombards the strip with airstrikes.
For “Israeli ground offensive,” substitute massive military assault. Note the mention of hostages held by Hamas but no mention of hostages/prisoners held by Israel. “Besieged enclave”–open-air prison or concentration camp under constant bombing would be more telling. “Dismantle Hamas”: the IDF goal is the total destruction of Hamas, with the death of civilians being blamed on Hamas because “they” allegedly use human shields, i.e. the Israeli government and military is never to blame.
Note the passive voice: 4600 people “have been killed in Gaza” — well, who’s killed them? Who’s wounded 14,200 others? With weapons provided by which countries?
Conditions in Gaza continue to “deteriorate”: What does this mean, specifically? Lack of food, water, power, people dying in hospitals due to lack of supplies, people screaming in agony due to lack of anaesthesia, etc. And why are they “deteriorating”? It’s not just due to airstrikes by Israel. The Israeli government’s decision to stop food, fuel, electricity, and water to Gaza is creating the conditions for death and illness on a massive scale.
Caitlin Johnstone has a fine critique about how Israeli bombing is being reported by the Western press. In essence, it’s reported as if bombs are simply dropping from the sky on Gaza: massive bombing as a very bad hail storm that must be endured and over which humans have no control.
Pay very close attention to how this war is being reported, especially in the Western mainstream press. For we all know the saying that the first casualty of war is truth.
Update: I’m involved with an effort, “Words About War Matter,” and the group led by David Vine has posted guidance for language related to Israel, Hamas, and Gaza. The link is https://www.wordsaboutwar.org/gaza.html.
Bracing Views 
Do waring parties raise the white flag and negotiate a surrender anymore?
LikeLike
Thanks for the dose of sanity and reason.
Viva Palestine!
LikeLike
Thanks very much for the article. Personally I discount any conventional news reports re: Palestinians & Gaza. Except for Gideon Levy in Haaretz News or Marjorie Cohn, law professor, or Ilan Pappas, the Israeli Historian, there seem to be few reliable sources that are trustworthy.
LikeLike
Thank You, Bill, for that link to Words About War. It is a very valuable resource and asset for anybody who wants to actually, really think ~ let alone write, talk, or social medialize ~ about War. And not just the one in Gaza.
And Thank You for this article. It almost is beginning to sound like You are getting totally and completely fed up with all The Bullshit.
LikeLike
It’s true that language matters a lot in reporting about conflicts! I have often seen mainstream media use passive language for Palestinians e.g. “died” whereas Israelis are “killed”.
LikeLike